- ADA compliance
- demand letter
- lawsuit
- small business
ADA Website Demand Letter vs. Lawsuit: What's the Difference?
An ADA demand letter and an ADA lawsuit are not the same thing. Learn how they differ, what each one asks of you, and what to do next.
On this page
If you run a small business, an ADA website complaint can reach you in two very different ways. One is a letter. The other is a lawsuit. They can look alike at first glance, because both come from attorneys and both say your website keeps people with disabilities from using it.
But they are not the same thing, and the steps you take next depend on which one you have. This guide explains the difference in plain English.
This is not legal advice. ComplyKit is not a law firm. This article explains general concepts only. If you have received a letter or been served with a lawsuit, talk to an attorney about your situation right away.
The short version
- A demand letter is a letter. It is sent before any case is filed in court. It describes a complaint and asks you to do something, often fix your site and pay money, by a deadline.
- A lawsuit is a case that has been filed in a court. You usually learn about it when you are formally "served" with court papers, such as a summons and a complaint.
A letter is a warning that a lawsuit could follow. A lawsuit means the court process has already started.
What a demand letter is
A demand letter usually comes from a law firm representing a person with a disability. It typically:
- Says the person tried to use your website and ran into barriers
- Lists problems, such as images with no text description or forms that can't be used with a keyboard
- Mentions the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and sometimes state law
- Asks you to fix the website, and often to pay a settlement, by a set date
A demand letter is not a court order. Nobody has filed a case yet. That gives you a window to get advice, look at your website, and decide how to respond with your attorney.
It does not mean you should ignore it. A letter that goes unanswered can turn into a lawsuit. For a step-by-step plan, read Got an ADA Website Demand Letter? What Small Business Owners Should Do First.
What a lawsuit is
A lawsuit starts when someone files a complaint with a court. The complaint names you (or your business) as the defendant and describes what the plaintiff says you did wrong.
You are then formally served with the papers. Once that happens, court deadlines apply. In federal court, for example, Rule 12 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure generally gives a defendant 21 days after being served with the summons and complaint to serve an answer, or 60 days if the defendant agreed to waive formal service. State courts have their own rules and deadlines.
Missing a court deadline can have serious consequences, so a lawsuit calls for an attorney immediately, not next week.
How the ADA itself is enforced
The ADA has more than one enforcement path for businesses that are open to the public (Title III of the law). According to the Justice Department's ADA Title III Technical Assistance Manual:
- Private individuals can file a lawsuit asking a court for an injunction, which is an order to fix the problem. The manual says remedies in a private suit do not include compensatory or punitive money damages or civil penalties.
- Attorney's fees can be awarded to the party that wins, in addition to other relief. Under the manual, the prevailing party "may recover attorney's fees in addition to any other relief granted."
- The Department of Justice can investigate and can bring its own cases, where the available remedies can include civil penalties.
This describes the federal ADA only. A letter or lawsuit may also cite state law, which can work differently. Your attorney can tell you which laws apply where you do business.
Side-by-side: letter vs. lawsuit
Where it comes from
- Demand letter: an attorney, usually by mail or email
- Lawsuit: a court case, delivered through formal service of a summons and complaint
Is a court involved?
- Demand letter: not yet
- Lawsuit: yes
Deadlines
- Demand letter: a deadline set by the sender in the letter
- Lawsuit: deadlines set by court rules
What it usually asks for
- Demand letter: fix the site, and often a settlement payment
- Lawsuit: whatever the complaint asks the court to order, such as an injunction to fix the site, plus attorney's fees
Who you should call first
- Both: an attorney, ideally one who handles ADA or accessibility matters
What is the same in both cases
Whether you got a letter or a lawsuit, a few things are true either way.
Your website's real barriers matter
Both a letter and a lawsuit are about whether people with disabilities can use your site. The Justice Department's guidance on web accessibility lists common barriers, including poor color contrast, missing image descriptions, and navigation that only works with a mouse. Fixing the actual code of your site is what helps real visitors.
Documentation helps your attorney
A dated record of your site's accessibility problems, and of the fixes you make afterward, gives your attorney something concrete to work with. An automated scan is a quick way to start that record. It will not find every problem, and it is not a legal opinion, but it shows where you stand on a given date.
Quick-fix widgets are not a shortcut
Some products promise to make any site compliant with a single line of code. Be careful with those claims. Read Do Accessibility Overlay Widgets Make Your Website ADA Compliant? before you buy one.
What not to do
- Don't ignore either one. A letter can become a lawsuit, and a lawsuit has court deadlines.
- Don't respond on your own before talking to an attorney, and don't sign or pay anything first.
- Don't change your site and throw away the evidence. Make fixes, but keep a dated record of what the site looked like before and what you changed.
- Don't assume a score means you're done. No tool, ours included, can guarantee compliance or make a claim go away.
Not sure where your site stands?
Run a free scan of your homepage to see which detectable accessibility problems show up today, explained in plain English.
If you have a demand letter or a lawsuit in hand, the Demand Letter Response Kit ($199 one time) gives you a full scan of up to 5 pages, a dated PDF report to share with your attorney, a fix guide your web person can follow, and 30 days of weekly rescans to show your progress.
Want more background first? Read Does My Small Business Website Need to Be ADA Accessible?